Goodbye Cakey, Hello Glowy: Makeup Tips for Skin After 40

Turning 40 brought some unexpected changes to my beauty routine. Foundation, once a great friend, became a foe.

It looks cakey in natural light, emphasizing textures and my newly acquired static wrinkles. This transformation led me on a makeup adventure, allowing me to experiment with new products and techniques to achieve a fresh, glowing look (cough, cough, that used to be more effortless).

This article is for you if you’re over 40 and struggling with the same issues. I’ll take you through my updated routine, featuring innovative products like brightening primers, hydrating skin tints, and targeted concealers, all applied in a new order to enhance maturing skin.

Start With A Glowy, Multipurpose Primer

Aging skin needs a primer that helps makeup last and imparts coverage and skin-loving benefits.

It’s time to be the Goldilocks of primers: mature skin needs a primer that blurs, softens, and provides a bit of coverage and glow.

megan using RMS Super Serum as primer for over-40 makeup look
First step: spreading a glowy primer with my fingertips

How

Spread over the face after skincare and before any other makeup products.

Ish Mom Recommends

RMS Beauty SuperNatural Radiance Serum and Maybelline Super Stay 24Hr Skin Tint

Need More Glow?

Consider a radiance base. These products are wonderful for depositing glow without texture (in other words, they don’t get caught in fine lines and wrinkles).

How

This product can be used in lieu of, or in addition to, the multi-purpose primers listed above. Spread over your face with a complexion brush and pat in with a makeup sponge.

Blend well, or be sure to cover with skin tint or tinted moisturizer.

InnBeauty Project Face Glaze, RMS Beauty Radiance Base, TirTir Cushion Foundation

Ish Mom Recommends

Underpainting

Let’s call this step proto-coverage, correcting some issues before a tinted moisturizer or foundation goes over everything.

Ish Mom applying e.l.f. undereye brightener with ring finger
Applying undereye brightener with my ring finger

How

Use a color corrector under your eyes, and a concealer pencil (very precisely) on spots, veins, broken capillaries, etc.

Ish Mom using a K-Beauty pencil concealer to cover small imperfections on post-40 skin
Using a pencil concealer precisely on skin imperfections

If you’re feeling fancy, do some light contouring (along your jawline, under cheekbones, down the bridge of the nose, and in eye creases). Blend, but don’t go crazy, the final step will cover any mistakes.

Ish Mom using e.l.f. contour wand on post-40 jawline
Underpainting some cream contour on the jawline before applying base

Ish Mom Recommends

Ish Moms Favorite Undereye Products

Now, the Base

Foundation has looked too heavy on my aging skin; I’ve switched to skin tints and tinted moisturizers.

True, these products have slightly less coverage than traditional foundation. But we’re making up for that with the additional products (and the order in which they are applied).

How

Use a foundation brush or sponge to pat base makeup on the face, concentrating on areas that need the most coverage first.

Avoid the undereye area, if any more coverage is needed there, it’ll be addressed next.

Ish Mom using cushion foundation as the ideal base for aging skin
Patting on my favorite TirTir cushion foundation as base

Ish Mom Recommends

Spot Conceal

After blending the base, take a step back and assess your work.

Anything you don’t like (dark undereye circles, pimples, etc) still peeking through? Apply concealer just to those areas.

Ish Mom using Maybelline Age Rewind concealer on dark undereye circles
Getting the last of my dark circles with a final application of concealer

How

Warm up some concealer on your hand and use a small brush to blend a small amount (precisely).

Ish Mom Recommends

Cream (or Liquid!) Products

Now that your face is all one color (except for the areas that have been contoured), it’s time to bring some color to the party.

Every face makeup product exists in a cream or liquid formula. And middle age is the best time to get to know them all.

Ish Mom applying RMS Lip2Cheek directly to cheekbones to sculpt an aging face
Using my fingertips to apply cream blush directly to my cheekbones

How

Use your fingertips or a brush to apply cream (or liquid!) blush, bronzer, and/or highlight. Tap with a sponge to make sure the products are thoroughly melded to skin.

Ish Mom Recommends

Ish Mom's collection of cream blush
So many cream face products…

Layer and Set

Applying a setting or finishing powder and finishing with setting spray can be the last steps for an amazing post-40 makeup look.

If makeup really needs to last, layer complimentary powder formulas of face makeup products as well.

Ish Mom applying RMS Beauty loose powder to set over age 40 makeup look
Using loose powder to set all those cream formulas

How

Swirl a large brush into loose powder and pat over face.

If layering, apply powder blush, highlighter, etc, then mist setting spray over everything.

RMS Beauty UnPowder, e.l.f. bitesize blush and highlighter, Rare Beauty powder blush
Some of my favorite powders for setting and layering

Ish Mom Recommends

Conclusion

Face makeup after age 40 is all about strategic product placement and multitasking. By using more products in smaller amounts, you can enhance your natural beauty without overwhelming maturing skin.

Remember, it’s not about working harder, but smarter—opt for makeup that doubles as skincare to nourish and protect while providing coverage.

Ish Mom's final makeup look for post-40 skin
Finished look!

Want More?

Check out these articles about makeup and skincare:

Happy Glowing!

Love,

megan imhoff
Picture of Megan

Megan

Megan writes everything on Ish Mom. She possesses a bachelor's degree in psychology, a flair for theatrics, and a whole lotta nerve. She lives in the Midwest (and loves it) with her wonderful husband and three young boys.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Sign up and get exclusive content not shared anywhere else!